08/09/26 – When Life Isn’t Fair – Matthew 14:22–33
August 9, 2026
Grace, mercy, and peace be to you from God our Father and from our Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ. Amen.
When the Journey Leads into a Storm
Last week, as we began our Bread for the Journey series, we stood beside thousands of hungry people on a hillside in Galilee. Jesus took five loaves and two fish, He gave thanks, and fed them all. The disciples gathered twelve baskets of leftovers, reminding us our Lord always provides more than enough for His people. Jesus Himself is the Bread for the Journey.
Today’s Gospel begins only hours later. The crowds have gone home. The disciples climb into their boat while Jesus goes up the mountain to pray. It seems the day should end in quiet peace. Then, the storm begins.
That is often how life feels. One day everything appears to be going well. The next day a doctor’s phone call changes everything. A loved one dies. A relationship falls apart. A child wanders from the faith. Suddenly the peaceful road becomes difficult, and we find ourselves asking questions we never expected to ask.
You’ve probably asked them. “Lord, why is this happening?” “Why didn’t You stop it?” “What are You doing?” “Are You there?” Those questions aren’t unique to you. They have been asked by God’s people throughout history. Job asked them. David asked them. Jeremiah asked them. The difference is not whether believers ask questions. The difference is where those questions finally lead.
God Gives Job Himself
If anyone deserved an explanation, it was Job. In a short time he lost his wealth, his children, and his health. Even his friends turned into prosecutors and persecutors. For chapter after chapter he cried out to God, asking, “Why?!”
Finally the Lord answers, but instead of explaining everything, God asked His own questions:
Where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth?1
Who set limits on the boundaries of the sea?2
Who rules over all creation?
God was not avoiding Job’s questions. He was reminding Job who was answering them. Job could see only one page. God saw the whole book. By the end Job doesn’t say, “Now I understand everything.” He confessed to knows the Lord more deeply.3 God gave Job something greater than explanations. He gave Job Himself. That prepares us perfectly for today’s Gospel.
Christ Comes into the Storm
The last reading for today takes us from Job’s home in the ancient and distant land of Uz to the Sea of Galilee, but the questions haven’t changed. Job wondered why God had allowed suffering in his life. The disciples are about to discover the answer to our deepest questions is not an explanation but the presence of Jesus.
Matthew tells us the disciples were exactly where Jesus had told them to be. That’s important to notice. They weren’t caught in the storm because they had wandered away from Him. They were in the middle of the storm because they had obeyed Him. That’s an important reminder for us. Faithfulness does not exempt God’s people from hardship. Sometimes God leads us into places where our faith will be strengthened by learning to depend on Him more.
As the night wore on, the wind grew stronger and the waves beat against the boat.4 The disciples strained at the oars for hours, making little progress. You might know what that’s like. I remember our family heading out onto to small lake in canoes. My wife and son in one and our daughter with me. As we were about to head back the wind picked up.
My wife and son were strong enough to turn against the wind and row back to shore. My daughter was only six or seven. She made a far better sail then anything else. We had to turn and I started cranking on that oar. Every time I pulled to canoe turned a bit, when I pulled it out of the water to bring it back the wind pushed the front of the canoe back away from shore.
We made a very wide, slow turn. Then we had to row against the wind all the way back to shore. The wind was constantly trying to turn the canoe back out into the lake. I kept cranking and cranking on that oar. My daughter, as I recall, spent most of the time giggling as she watched me work. Obviously, since we’re here, we made it back to shore.
Maybe you’ve known time in life like that. You continue praying. You continue worshiping. You continue trusting God’s promises. You steal yourself against the storm. Yet the storm doesn’t end.
For the disciples that night, just before dawn, Jesus came. Not after the storm. Not after the wind stopped. He came while the storm was still raging. That’s one of the most comforting details in this entire account. Jesus does not wait until life becomes easy before coming to His people. He comes while the wind is still blowing.
At first the disciples did not recognize Him. Fear often clouds our vision. The very One who had come to save them seemed, for a moment, to be another reason to be afraid. Then Jesus spoke the words every concerned heart needs to hear “Take heart; it is I. Do not be afraid.5”
It is worth some time to pause at those words because they reveal more than just His presence. They reveal His identity. The Lord who created the sea and questioned Job about its limits, now stands on the sea He created. Those words, “It is I” lose something profound in the translation.
Jesus did not just say, “Hey guys I’m here.” He said “I AM” is here. Matthew records Jesus words ἐγώ εἰμι [ego ay-me] I AM. The very name of God given by God to Moses. Jesus did just say I’m here. He said “I AM is here.” “The God of creation is here.”
Then the most remarkable thing happens. Peter steps out of the boat and begins walking toward Jesus. For a few moments everything is fine. His eyes are fixed on Jesus. Then he notices the wind. Fear replaces confidence and he begins to sink.6
Isn’t that all to often our story? We begin by looking to Jesus. Then our attention shifts to the diagnosis, the bills, the family conflict, or the uncertainty about tomorrow. Before long we are measuring the size of the storm instead of the faithfulness of our Savior. As Peter sinks beneath the waves, he prays one short but profound prayer: “Lord, save me!7”
Matthew immediately tells us Jesus reached out His hand and took hold of him.8 Only after Peter is safely in His grasp does Jesus ask why he doubted. He doesn’t condemn Peter for having weak faith. He reminds him that even weak faith has a mighty Savior. That is our comfort too.
In the Small Catechism we confess in Luther’s explanation to the Third Article of the Creed:
We cannot by our own reason or strength believe in Jesus Christ our Lord.
The Holy Spirit creates and sustains that faith through the Gospel. Our confidence has never rested on the strength of our faith. It has always rested on the strength of our Savior. Peter’s faith was weak. Christ’s hand was strong. It still is.
Christ Gives Us Himself
Peter’s rescue points us to an even greater one. The greatest unfairness the world has ever known was not Job’s suffering or Peter’s fear. It was the suffering of the sinless Son of God. Isaiah foretold that the promised Messiah would carry our sins and suffer in our place.9
On the cross Jesus entered the greatest storm of all. He suffered under the judgment we deserved so we could receive the forgiveness we could never earn. That is why the cross forever answers the question of God’s love.
We may not understand why every hardship comes, but we never need to wonder whether God loves us. The cross has settled that forever. As St. Paul reminds us:
The Father who did not spare His own Son will certainly not abandon those whom His Son has redeemed.10
Where does that comfort come to us today? Paul gives a wonderfully simple answer:
Faith comes from hearing.11
God still comes to His people through His Word. He speaks forgiveness through Holy Absolution. He adopts us in Holy Baptism. He feeds us with His true Body and Blood in the Holy Supper. The Psalm invites us to taste and see that the Lord is good.12 Every Divine Service is another reminder Jesus has not left you. He continues to give Himself to you until the journey is complete.
That is why this series is called Bread for the Journey. Jesus does not simply prepare us for a future heaven. He faithfully provides exactly what we need for today.
Conclusion — Enough for Today
Reading these things from the Bible together, we notice what Job and Peter have in common. Neither one received what he thought he needed. Job thought he needed an explanation. Peter thought he needed stronger faith. Instead, both received something infinitely better. They received Jesus.
Job encountered the majesty of the Creator. Peter experienced the saving hand of the Savior. Neither man suddenly understood every mystery. Both learned the presence of God is greater than an explanation from God. That is where the Christian life is lived.
There are many questions we may never have answered in this life, but we have been given something far more certain than explanations. We have been given Jesus Christ. That is our hope.
The same Lord who stood before Job… The same Lord who walked on the sea… The same Lord who stretched out His hand to Peter… The same Lord who stretched out His hands on the cross… is the Lord who stands with you today. His promises have not changed. His mercy has not changed. His love has not changed. So when the storm comes remember His words:
Take heart; it is I. Do not be afraid.13
Amen.
=======
NOTES
1Job 38:4
2Job 38:8–11
3Job 42:5
4Matthew 14:24
5Matthew 14:27
6Matthew 14:29–30
7Matthew 14:30
8Matthew 14:31
9Isaiah 53:5
10Romans 8:32
11Romans 10:17
12Psalm 34:8
13Matthew 14:27
As We Gather
Life often seems unfair. We naturally want explanations for suffering, but God gives us something greater than answers, He gives us Himself. As Jesus came to His frightened disciples on the stormy sea, so He continues to come to His Church through His Word and Sacraments. Our confidence rests not in understanding every circumstance, but in Christ’s faithful presence throughout the journey.
Prayer Before Service
O Lord God, You have called us through Your holy Word. Send now Your Holy Spirit that we may gladly hear, faithfully believe, and joyfully follow Your Son, Jesus Christ, who lives and reigns forever. Amen.
Historical notes:
Written by Martin Luther, he encouraged pastors and congregations to pray before hearing God’s Word, emphasizing that faith is the work of the Holy Spirit through the Gospel.
Leave a Reply